Interview

Cli­ni­cal eva­lua­ti­on of dif­fe­rent ank­le joint stiff­nes­ses – A modu­lar test­ing ortho­sis as a tool for cus­to­mi­zed AFO treatment

Christina Krieger1, Ole Strenge2, Carsten Dilthey3, Juliane Wühr4, David Hochmann2, Carsten Kramer1, Ulrich Hafkemeyer5
This article describes the development and testing of a modular testing orthosis as a tool for everyday clinical practice. The orthosis allows for variation in stiffness around the ankle joint and the metatarsophalangeal joints, as well as adjustment of the neutral angle at the ankle joint. It is intended to serve as a tool for selecting orthotic configurations that best meet the individual treatment goals of patients. In an initial study, the orthosis was tested on a subject with lower-limb-predominant spastic hemiparesis and a retrograde gait pattern. The fundamental applicability of the concept in routine clinical practice was confirmed. The results form the basis for further research on objective decision-making and the application of the findings to definitive treatments.


1  Kom­pe­tenz­zen­trum Kra­mer, Papen­burg
2  Labor für Bio­me­cha­tro­nik, FH Müns­ter, Stein­furt
3  MUUV GmbH, Müns­ter
4  Sozi­al­päd­ia­tri­sches Zen­trum West­müns­ter­land, Coes­feld
5  Sozi­al-Päd­ia­tri­sches Ambu­lanz- und ­The­ra­pie­zen­trum SPATZ, Meppen

 

Intro­duc­tion

Dyna­mic ank­le-foot ort­ho­ses (AFOs) are assis­ti­ve devices desi­gned to sup­port pati­ents with abnor­mal gait pat­terns [1]. AFOs are used in various neu­ro­lo­gi­cal and mus­cu­los­ke­le­tal con­di­ti­ons to sta­bi­li­ze and pro­vi­de func­tion­al sup­port to the lower extre­mi­ties during ambu­la­ti­on [2]. Their effect is pri­ma­ri­ly based on the trans­fer of resis­ti­ve tor­ques to the patient’s lower extre­mi­ties [3].

The rela­ti­onship bet­ween the­se resis­ti­ve tor­ques and the AFO’s defor­ma­ti­on ang­le is refer­red to as AFO stiff­ness. A distinc­tion is made pri­ma­ri­ly bet­ween stiff­ness around the ank­le joint and the meta­tar­so­phal­an­ge­al joints. The lite­ra­tu­re gene­ral­ly assu­mes a line­ar rela­ti­onship, such that an ortho­sis can be cha­rac­te­ri­zed by its ank­le and foot­p­la­te stiff­ness [4].

Stu­dies show that ank­le joint stiff­ness, in par­ti­cu­lar, is a key fac­tor in the qua­li­ty of the tre­at­ment pro­vi­ded [5] (for infor­ma­ti­on on the influence of ank­le stiff­ness on patho­lo­gi­cal gait pat­terns, see, e.g., [3, 5–13]). At the same time, AFO stiff­ness should be tail­o­red indi­vi­du­al­ly to each pati­ent and depends on the tre­at­ment goal as well as on fac­tors such as patho­lo­gy, mus­cle tone, and ana­to­my [6, 7]. Appro­pria­te care the­r­e­fo­re requi­res that the stiff­ness of the ort­ho­ses be tail­o­red as pre­cis­e­ly as pos­si­ble to each patient’s spe­ci­fic gait disorder.

In cli­ni­cal prac­ti­ce, the ank­le and foot­p­la­te stiff­ness of AFOs are often deter­mi­ned based on gait ana­ly­sis mea­su­re­ments, the expe­ri­ence of ortho­tic spe­cia­lists, and cli­ni­cal exami­na­ti­on results. Howe­ver, in prac­ti­ce, it is usual­ly unclear whe­ther the inten­ded tre­at­ment goal has been achie­ved until the ortho­sis has been manu­fac­tu­red and its func­tion­a­li­ty has been asses­sed on the pati­ent. This makes it dif­fi­cult to tail­or AFO stiff­ness in a sys­te­ma­tic and tar­ge­ted man­ner. A tool that allows the appro­pria­te stiff­ness con­fi­gu­ra­ti­on to be deter­mi­ned even befo­re the final AFO is manu­fac­tu­red could faci­li­ta­te indi­vi­du­al cus­to­miza­ti­on and also help crea­te a lar­ger data­set for com­pu­ter-aided tre­at­ment con­cepts (see, e.g., [14]).

In the lite­ra­tu­re, the­re are various stu­dies on the effect of AFO ank­le stiff­ness on the gait pat­tern of dif­fe­rent pati­ent groups. For this pur­po­se, arti­cu­la­ted ort­ho­ses with inter­ch­an­geable func­tion­al ele­ments of vary­ing stiff­ness [8–10] or pas­si­ve-dyna­mic AFOs with varia­ble dyna­mic ele­ments were used [11–13]. Howe­ver, the­se stu­dies focu­sed on inves­ti­ga­ting the effect of stiff­ness on the patho­lo­gi­cal gait pat­tern rather than on deve­lo­ping a tool that could be used in ever­y­day cli­ni­cal prac­ti­ce. Sin­ce the­se AFOs were cus­to­mi­zed for each indi­vi­du­al, the sys­tems used are only of limi­t­ed sui­ta­bi­li­ty for such a purpose.

The­r­e­fo­re, as part of the ERDF/JTF pro­ject “INDi­GO,” a test­ing ortho­sis was deve­lo­ped at a Ger­man ortho­pe­dic work­shop (Kom­pe­tenz­zen­trum Kra­mer, Papen­burg, Ger­ma­ny) in coope­ra­ti­on with Müns­ter Uni­ver­si­ty of Appli­ed Sci­en­ces (Stein­furt, Ger­ma­ny) and MUUV GmbH (Müns­ter, Ger­ma­ny). It is based on the dyna­mic pre­preg AFO fol­lo­wing Haf­ke­mey­er, which has been used in Ger­ma­ny sin­ce 2006 for various neu­ro­or­tho­pe­dic con­di­ti­ons [15], and is the pri­ma­ry tre­at­ment form pro­vi­ded at the workshop.

Using the test­ing ortho­sis, the AFO’s ank­le and foot­p­la­te stiff­ness, as well as its neu­tral ang­le rela­ti­ve to the ank­le joint, can be varied, while the ortho­sis size can be adapt­ed to the patient’s ana­to­my. It is inten­ded to help inves­ti­ga­te the influence of dif­fe­rent AFO stiff­ness levels on the gait pat­tern of pati­ents with patho­lo­gi­cal gait, in order to iden­ti­fy the most sui­ta­ble AFO con­fi­gu­ra­ti­on for this AFO type even befo­re the final device is manufactured.

A preli­mi­na­ry stu­dy was con­duc­ted to assess its appli­ca­bi­li­ty in ever­y­day cli­ni­cal prac­ti­ce. Using the test­ing ortho­sis, an instru­men­ted gait ana­ly­sis was per­for­med to exami­ne the effect of stiff­ness varia­ti­on on a subject’s gait pat­tern. Sub­se­quent­ly, the tes­ted AFO con­fi­gu­ra­ti­ons were eva­lua­ted based on the gait ana­ly­sis data with regard to the defi­ned tre­at­ment goal.

This artic­le descri­bes the spe­ci­fi­ca­ti­ons of this test­ing ortho­sis as well as the results of the study.

Methods

Cha­rac­te­riza­ti­on of the Test­ing Orthosis

Gene­ral Concept

The test­ing ortho­sis is based on a modu­lar sys­tem that can be adapt­ed to dif­fe­rent pati­ent ana­to­mies by com­bi­ning pre­fa­bri­ca­ted com­pon­ents. Calf and foot shells in various sizes (shoe sizes 30–45) as well as leaf spring ele­ments (AFO struts) of dif­fe­rent lengths are available for this pur­po­se and can be com­bi­ned as nee­ded. The stiff­ness of the ank­le and foot­p­la­te com­pon­ents can be adjus­ted inde­pendent­ly of one ano­ther by swap­ping out spring ele­ments with dif­fe­rent stiff­ness levels. Addi­tio­nal­ly, the neu­tral ang­le of the AFO around the ank­le joint can be adjus­ted in incre­ments. To repli­ca­te the roll-off beha­vi­or of an AFO insi­de a shoe, the ortho­sis is equip­ped with an inte­gra­ted shoe sole (Fig. 1).

Varia­ti­on of Ank­le Stiff­ness and Ortho­sis Height

The ortho­sis height and its ank­le stiff­ness can be adjus­ted by repla­cing car­bon AFO struts of dif­fe­rent lengths and fle­xu­ral stiff­nes­ses. The struts are screwed onto the foot shell of the ortho­sis. For more pre­cise adjus­t­ment of the ortho­sis height, the calf shell can be adjus­ted to dif­fe­rent heights along the AFO struts using star-head screws (Fig. 2).

Varia­ti­on of Foot­p­la­te Stiffness

The stiff­ness of the foot­p­la­te can also be adjus­ted by repla­cing various fore­foot spring ele­ments. To do this, the appro­pria­te fore­foot ele­ment is inser­ted into the foot shell and secu­red to the side of the shell using screws (Fig. 3).

Varia­ti­on of Ank­le Neu­tral Angle

The ank­le neu­tral ang­le is adjus­ted by inser­ting pre­de­fi­ned wed­ges bet­ween the foot shell and the AFO strut. It is pos­si­ble to vary the ank­le joint ang­le bet­ween 10° plant­ar­fle­xi­on and 10° dor­si­fle­xi­on. The ank­le neu­tral ang­le, as defi­ned in ortho­pe­dic tech­no­lo­gy, refers exclu­si­ve­ly to the ang­le bet­ween the calf shell and the foot shell. A neu­tral ang­le of 0° cor­re­sponds to a 90° ang­le bet­ween the two com­pon­ents. The inte­gra­ted shoe sole also fea­tures a heel-to-toe drop, which alters the ori­en­ta­ti­on of the ortho­sis and makes it appear dor­si­fle­xed. This is inten­ded to repli­ca­te the real-world situa­ti­on with an AFO in an off-the-shelf shoe (Fig. 4).

Stu­dy

This stu­dy ser­ves as an initi­al basis for deter­mi­ning whe­ther the test­ing ortho­sis can be used in ever­y­day cli­ni­cal prac­ti­ce to iden­ti­fy sui­ta­ble, pati­ent-spe­ci­fic AFO con­fi­gu­ra­ti­ons. Sin­ce the lite­ra­tu­re pri­ma­ri­ly con­siders ank­le stiff­ness to be rele­vant to the qua­li­ty of pati­ent care [16], and sin­ce the many pos­si­ble varia­ti­ons result in an extre­me­ly lar­ge num­ber of poten­ti­al AFO con­fi­gu­ra­ti­ons, this stu­dy varied only the ank­le stiff­ness of the test­ing ortho­sis. Howe­ver, fur­ther stu­dies are plan­ned to com­pre­hen­si­ve­ly inves­ti­ga­te the appli­ca­bi­li­ty of the test­ing orthosis.

Sub­ject Description

The stu­dy sub­ject (male, 17 years old, 181 cm, 76 kg) pres­ents with uni­la­te­ral spas­tic hemi­pa­re­sis pre­do­mi­nant­ly affec­ting the left lower extre­mi­ty. This is accom­pa­nied by shor­tening of the left tri­ceps surae mus­cle with func­tion­al equi­nus defor­mi­ty, as well as a leg length dis­crepan­cy favoring the right side. For seve­ral years, the sub­ject has been fit­ted with a dyna­mic AFO based on the Haf­ke­mey­er design, which has led to an impro­ve­ment in gait qua­li­ty and sta­bi­li­ty, as well as a more phy­sio­lo­gi­cal gait pattern.

When wal­king bare­foot, an alter­na­ting gait pat­tern is obser­ved, with the left side being cle­ar­ly shor­ten­ed, cha­rac­te­ri­zed by pri­ma­ry fore­foot cont­act fol­lo­wed by heel loa­ding, con­sis­tent with a retro­gra­de gait pat­tern. During the stance pha­se, knee fle­xi­on remains increased on the left side com­pared to the right, and full knee exten­si­on can­not be achie­ved due to increased mus­cle tone in the knee flex­ors. Addi­tio­nal­ly, during the swing pha­se, acti­ve dor­si­fle­xi­on at the ank­le joint is rest­ric­ted due to the increased mus­cle tone.

In the lower extre­mi­ties, pas­si­ve ran­ge of moti­on in the hip and knee joints is lar­ge­ly sym­me­tri­cal. In the ank­le joint, the­re is limi­t­ed dor­si­fle­xi­on on the left side due to shor­tening of the tri­ceps surae mus­cle. The full ran­ge of moti­on of the lower extre­mi­ties is shown in Table 1. Based on the mus­cle assess­ment accor­ding to Jan­da [17], the affec­ted left side pre­do­mi­nant­ly show­ed strength gra­de 4, while the hip mus­cles show­ed strength gra­de 5. The unaf­fec­ted right side was nor­mal throug­hout. This is shown in Table 2.

In order to eva­lua­te the dif­fe­rent ank­le stiff­ness levels, an indi­vi­dua­li­zed tre­at­ment goal was defi­ned befo­re the start of the tri­al. This ser­ved as a refe­rence for asses­sing the various AFO con­fi­gu­ra­ti­ons. The tre­at­ment goal was defi­ned as fol­lows: Abo­ve all, the ortho­sis must ensu­re initi­al heel cont­act and a ful­ly ante­ro­gra­de rol­ling move­ment of the foot in order to gene­ra­te an exter­nal plant­ar­flex­ing tor­que in the ank­le joint and an exter­nal flex­ing tor­que in the knee during weight accep­tance, ther­eby achie­ving more phy­sio­lo­gi­cal knee kine­ma­tics. In addi­ti­on, during the mid-stance pha­se, the ortho­sis should sup­port the gene­ra­ti­on of a knee exten­si­on tor­que and phy­sio­lo­gi­cal dor­si­fle­xi­on of the ank­le joint.

Tes­ted AFO Configurations

Based on the subject’s medi­cal records, which were available pri­or to the stu­dy, the ortho­sis height, the ank­le neu­tral ang­le, and the foot­p­la­te stiff­ness of the test­ing ortho­sis to be eva­lua­ted were deter­mi­ned in advan­ce. In addi­ti­on, AFO struts in three dif­fe­rent stiff­ness levels were sel­ec­ted. This resul­ted in three AFO con­fi­gu­ra­ti­ons (C1–C3) which were dee­med appro­pria­te by the work­shop and are fre­quent­ly used in rou­ti­ne cli­ni­cal prac­ti­ce. The three con­fi­gu­ra­ti­ons were then cha­rac­te­ri­zed and tes­ted by the Bio­me­cha­tro­nics Rese­arch Labo­ra­to­ry (FH Müns­ter Uni­ver­si­ty of Appli­ed Sci­en­ces, Stein­furt, Ger­ma­ny). The test­ing tech­no­lo­gy used is descri­bed in [18]. The spe­ci­fi­ca­ti­ons of the resul­ting ortho­sis con­fi­gu­ra­ti­ons are lis­ted in Table 3.

Stu­dy Protocol

The stu­dy was con­duc­ted in the gait ana­ly­sis labo­ra­to­ry of the Social Pedia­tric Cen­ter (SPZ) West­müns­ter­land in Coes­feld, Ger­ma­ny. The sub­ject first wal­ked bare­foot (BF) and then with three dif­fe­rent AFO con­fi­gu­ra­ti­ons in a ran­do­mi­zed order on a twel­ve-meter-long gait ana­ly­sis track (mea­su­re­ment distance appro­xi­m­ate­ly nine meters). Kine­ma­tic gait para­me­ters were recor­ded using the Vicon Nexus 2.18 sys­tem (mar­ker model: Vicon Plug-in-Gait lower body; Vicon Moti­on Sys­tems Ltd, Yarn­ton, United King­dom), and ground reac­tion forces were mea­su­red using two OR6‑6 force pla­tes (AMTI, Water­town, USA). Each con­fi­gu­ra­ti­on was mea­su­red until the force pla­tes were struck repro­du­ci­b­ly five times across their enti­re sur­face by the affec­ted foot. The­se five mea­su­re­ments ser­ved as the basis for cal­cu­la­ting mean values and stan­dard devia­ti­ons (SD).

Each mea­su­re­ment run was fol­lo­wed by a ten-minu­te break and a five-minu­te accli­ma­tiza­ti­on peri­od for the next con­fi­gu­ra­ti­on. In addi­ti­on, the repla­ce­ment time of the struts was docu­men­ted, and the sub­ject was asked about pain, pres­su­re points, or other complications.

Alt­hough some stu­dies objec­tively deter­mi­ne the opti­mal pati­ent-spe­ci­fic ank­le stiff­ness using respi­ra­to­ry gas ana­ly­sis or pul­se mea­su­re­ments, the­re is curr­ent­ly no stan­dard for deter­mi­ning the best AFO con­fi­gu­ra­ti­on [10, 13]. The­r­e­fo­re, and sin­ce the­se mea­su­re­ment methods are rare­ly used in the tre­at­ment approach addres­sed here, a prac­ti­cal but sub­jec­ti­ve approach was cho­sen for this stu­dy. The con­fi­gu­ra­ti­ons were eva­lua­ted by cli­ni­cal staff at the SPZ West­müns­ter­land and ortho­pe­dic tech­ni­ci­ans at the col­la­bo­ra­ting work­shop after the mea­su­re­ments were completed.

Results and Discussion

Hand­ling of the Test­ing Orthosis

No abnor­ma­li­ties were obser­ved during the cour­se of the stu­dy. The same appli­es to the hand­ling of the test­ing ortho­sis. The sub­ject also repor­ted no pain or other com­pli­ca­ti­ons. The time requi­red to replace the spring ele­ments aver­a­ged 87.80 s ± 10.47 s.

Gait Ana­ly­sis

The results of the stu­dy are pre­sen­ted in Table 4. Figu­re 5 shows the cur­ves from the gait ana­ly­sis. The ank­le ang­le reflects the ang­le bet­ween the foot shell of the ortho­sis and the subject’s lower leg and the­r­e­fo­re does not cor­re­spond to the ana­to­mic­al ang­le of moti­on in the subject’s ank­le joint.

To avo­id con­fu­si­on regar­ding the nomen­cla­tu­re and sign con­ven­ti­ons for tor­ques, only exter­nal tor­ques are spe­ci­fied below. Thus, a plant­ar­flex­ing tor­que at the ank­le joint is repre­sen­ted by a nega­ti­ve value, while a dor­si­flex­ing tor­que is repre­sen­ted by a posi­ti­ve value; simi­lar­ly, knee exten­si­on tor­ques are repre­sen­ted by nega­ti­ve values and knee fle­xi­on tor­ques by posi­ti­ve values.

The cur­ves show that all three AFO con­fi­gu­ra­ti­ons result in clear chan­ges com­pared to bare­foot wal­king. In all con­fi­gu­ra­ti­ons, initi­al heel cont­act is achie­ved, as evi­den­ced by the onset of a knee-exten­ding tor­que and a plant­ar­flex­ing ank­le tor­que, as well as a redu­ced plant­ar­fle­xi­on ang­le during weight accep­tance. The shock absorp­ti­on pha­se impro­ves due to a knee fle­xi­on tor­que that approa­ches the nor­mal ran­ge. Posi­ti­ve effects are also evi­dent in the mid-stance pha­se, par­ti­cu­lar­ly due to a knee exten­si­on tor­que and an increased dor­si­fle­xi­on ang­le, which, con­tra­ry to what would be expec­ted based on lite­ra­tu­re values, exhi­bits the same maxi­mum in all con­fi­gu­ra­ti­ons [3]. In addi­ti­on, the maxi­mum knee fle­xi­on ang­le increa­ses during the swing pha­se, allo­wing the con­tra­la­te­ral side to approach the phy­sio­lo­gi­cal range.

Posi­ti­ve effects on gait pat­terns are also obser­ved in the func­tion­al para­me­ters. Spe­ci­fi­cal­ly, wal­king speed increa­ses while cadence decrea­ses in each con­fi­gu­ra­ti­on, resul­ting in an increase in stri­de length.

All the­se aspects demons­tra­te that wea­ring the test­ing ortho­sis in each of the three con­fi­gu­ra­ti­ons leads to a clear impro­ve­ment in gait and ful­fills the pre­vious­ly defi­ned tre­at­ment goals. Nevert­hel­ess, distinc­tions can be made bet­ween the con­fi­gu­ra­ti­ons to deter­mi­ne the most sui­ta­ble one. Among the tre­at­ment goals, weight accep­tance emer­ged as the most cri­ti­cal gait pha­se for tre­at­ment qua­li­ty. For this reason, the cur­ves of the ank­le joint tor­que and the knee ang­le during this gait pha­se were spe­ci­fi­cal­ly used as the basis for decis­i­on-making. In con­trast to C1 and C2, C3 exhi­bi­ted an unphy­sio­lo­gi­cal­ly pro­lon­ged plant­ar­fle­xi­on tor­que with a second peak at appro­xi­m­ate­ly 15 % of the gait cycle and is the­r­e­fo­re rated as more unfa­vorable. The knee ang­le cur­ves also show that the sub­ject exhi­bits redu­ced shock absorp­ti­on during weight accep­tance with C1 com­pared to C2 and C3, as evi­den­ced by the smal­ler dif­fe­rence bet­ween the knee ang­le at initi­al cont­act and the maxi­mum fle­xi­on ang­le during loa­ding response.

The addi­tio­nal vide­os also show a high angu­lar velo­ci­ty in the ank­le joint during weight accep­tance with C1, while C3 appears to rest­rict the subject’s gait cycle too much. Sin­ce the remai­ning cur­ves show litt­le dif­fe­rence among the three con­fi­gu­ra­ti­ons, it can be assu­med that C2 is the most sui­ta­ble AFO con­fi­gu­ra­ti­on for the sub­ject among the three tes­ted con­fi­gu­ra­ti­ons. This illus­tra­tes that the tre­at­ment goal can be achie­ved with a dyna­mic AFO based on the Haf­ke­mey­er design, and pro­vi­des a refe­rence point for deter­mi­ning which of the tes­ted con­fi­gu­ra­ti­ons best achie­ves this goal.

Limi­ta­ti­ons and Conclusion

The stu­dy descri­bed in this artic­le sup­ports the hypo­the­sis that the pre­sen­ted test­ing ortho­sis can be used in ever­y­day cli­ni­cal prac­ti­ce as a tool for iden­ti­fy­ing a sui­ta­ble AFO con­fi­gu­ra­ti­on in the Haf­ke­mey­er design for pati­ents with abnor­mal gait pat­terns. Of the three con­fi­gu­ra­ti­ons tes­ted with a wide ran­ge of ank­le joint stiff­ness, the C2 con­fi­gu­ra­ti­on was sel­ec­ted as the one that best meets the inten­ded tre­at­ment goal, based on an eva­lua­ti­on by cli­ni­cal and ortho­pe­dic tech­ni­cal spe­cia­lists. The results also pro­vi­de a basis for fur­ther stu­dies in which, in addi­ti­on to ank­le stiff­ness, foot­p­la­te stiff­ness, the ank­le neu­tral ang­le, and, if neces­sa­ry, other para­me­ters will be varied to inves­ti­ga­te their influence on gait.

The test­ing ortho­sis can be used to eva­lua­te AFO con­fi­gu­ra­ti­ons in the Haf­ke­mey­er design, ther­eby estab­li­shing a foun­da­ti­on for the sys­te­ma­tic eva­lua­ti­on of this type of AFO. The cur­rent design of the test­ing ortho­sis is tail­o­red to this AFO type. Other AFO types that may also be effec­ti­ve (e.g., tho­se with a ven­tral fit) can­not curr­ent­ly be eva­lua­ted using this test­ing ortho­sis. It should also be noted that even wea­ring con­ven­tio­nal shoes can affect the patho­lo­gi­cal gait pat­tern. In this stu­dy, the effects of the various AFO con­fi­gu­ra­ti­ons were com­pared to the subject’s bare­foot gait; con­se­quent­ly, effects cau­sed by wea­ring only shoes were not con­side­red separately.

The stu­dy focu­sed on sel­ec­ting the most appro­pria­te AFO stiff­ness for each indi­vi­du­al from among the con­fi­gu­ra­ti­ons exami­ned. Due to the small sam­ple size of n = 1, the results should be con­side­red an iso­la­ted case and can­not be gene­ra­li­zed to other pati­ents. For the same reason, any devia­ti­ons from fin­dings in the lite­ra­tu­re (such as a con­sis­tent maxi­mum dor­si­fle­xi­on ang­le) are not dis­cus­sed here and should be inves­ti­ga­ted more spe­ci­fi­cal­ly in future studies.

The stu­dy also demons­tra­tes the fun­da­men­tal appli­ca­bi­li­ty of the test­ing ortho­sis as a tool for cli­ni­cal­ly test­ing dif­fe­rent AFO con­fi­gu­ra­ti­ons. Howe­ver, due to the modu­lar design, the adjus­ta­ble para­me­ters are only available in dis­crete steps, mea­ning that the opti­mal indi­vi­du­al con­fi­gu­ra­ti­on may lie bet­ween the­se steps. The dif­fe­rent ank­le stiff­nes­ses led to bio­me­cha­ni­cal­ly plau­si­ble chan­ges in the gait pha­ses rele­vant to the orthosis’s effect. At the same time, the gait ana­ly­sis cur­ves show­ed simi­lar pat­terns despi­te the com­pa­ra­tively lar­ge dif­fe­ren­ces in stiff­ness. This may indi­ca­te that the effects of finer stiff­ness gra­da­ti­ons can only be cap­tu­red to a limi­t­ed ext­ent with the mea­su­re­ment methods used. The role that pos­si­ble com­pen­sa­to­ry move­ments play in this con­text should be fur­ther inves­ti­ga­ted in stu­dies with lar­ger sam­ple sizes.

This high­lights the need for a more detail­ed and com­pre­hen­si­ve inves­ti­ga­ti­on of how dif­fe­rent ank­le stiff­ness levels affect the gait pat­tern of pati­ents with abnor­mal gait. The­re is also a rese­arch gap regar­ding how to iden­ti­fy the opti­mal, pati­ent-spe­ci­fic AFO con­fi­gu­ra­ti­on. In this stu­dy, the sel­ec­tion of the appro­pria­te con­fi­gu­ra­ti­on was based on cli­ni­cal and bio­me­cha­ni­cal eva­lua­tions con­duc­ted by the par­ti­ci­pa­ting health­ca­re pro­fes­sio­nals. Sin­ce this eva­lua­ti­on invol­ves a pro­fes­sio­nal inter­pre­ta­ti­on of the coll­ec­ted data, dif­fe­rent health­ca­re pro­fes­sio­nals may arri­ve at dif­fe­ring assessments.

Test­ing tools such as the test­ing ortho­sis pre­sen­ted here could enable the­se know­ledge gaps to be sys­te­ma­ti­cal­ly addres­sed in the long term and help deve­lop more objec­ti­ve decis­i­on-making cri­te­ria for tre­at­ment. The test­ing ortho­sis allows for a tar­ge­ted ana­ly­sis of how various design para­me­ters influence gait beha­vi­or. Fur­ther­mo­re, by main­tai­ning con­sis­tent test con­di­ti­ons, it can ser­ve as a basis for deve­lo­ping a decis­i­on-making gui­de that allows for a struc­tu­red and objec­ti­ve com­pa­ri­son of the qua­li­ty of care pro­vi­ded by dif­fe­rent AFO configurations.

To fur­ther inves­ti­ga­te this, Kom­pe­tenz­zen­trum Kra­mer, the SPZ West­müns­ter­land, and FH Müns­ter Uni­ver­si­ty of Appli­ed Sci­en­ces are plan­ning lar­ger-sca­le field tri­als. In the­se tri­als, foot­p­la­te stiff­ness and the ank­le neu­tral ang­le will also be varied in order to eva­lua­te the test­ing ortho­sis with respect to the­se para­me­ters and to exami­ne their influence on gait pat­terns. In addi­ti­on, an objec­ti­ve decis­i­on-making gui­de­line has been deve­lo­ped to compa­re the qua­li­ty of care pro­vi­ded by dif­fe­rent AFO con­fi­gu­ra­ti­ons for pati­ents with hemi­pa­re­sis and retro­gra­de roll-off beha­vi­or, and it will be tes­ted as part of the­se stu­dies. Fur­ther­mo­re, inves­ti­ga­ti­ons are ongo­ing into how the stiff­ness values iden­ti­fied as appro­pria­te using the test­ing ortho­sis can be trans­fer­red to the final AFO fit­ting (see, e.g., [20]).

In the long term, the goal is to test and vali­da­te a com­pre­hen­si­ve approach that will sup­ple­ment and sup­port expe­ri­ence-based decis­i­on-making in ortho­pe­dic tech­no­lo­gy with objec­ti­ve data, and inte­gra­te the insights gai­ned into ever­y­day AFO manu­fac­tu­ring processes.

 

Peer review­ed paper

 

Down­load PDF:

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

For Aut­hors:
Chris­ti­na Krie­ger
B. Eng. Tech­ni­sche Ortho­pä­die
Kom­pe­tenz­zen­trum Kra­mer
Gast­haus­ka­nal 2
26871 Papen­burg
c.krieger@kramer-gruppe.net

 

Cita­ti­on
Krie­ger C et al. Ver­schie­de­ne Sprung­ge­lenks­stei­fig­kei­ten kli­nisch erpro­ben – eine modu­la­re Test­or­the­se als Werk­zeug für die indi­vi­du­el­le AFO-Ver­sor­gung. Ortho­pä­die Tech­nik, 2026; 77 (11): 32–39

 

 

Figu­res and tables:

 

Refe­ren­ces

[1] Per­ry J, Burn­field JM. Gait ana­ly­sis: nor­mal and patho­lo­gi­cal func­tion. 2. Auf­la­ge. Tho­ro­fa­re, NJ: SLACK, 2010

[2] Zhou C, Yang Z, Li K, Ye X. Rese­arch and deve­lo­p­ment of ank­le-foot ort­ho­ses: a review. Sen­sors, 2022; 22 (17): 6596. doi: 10.3390/s22176596

[3] Tot­ah D et al. The impact of ank­le-foot ortho­sis stiff­ness on gait: a sys­te­ma­tic lite­ra­tu­re review. Gait & Pos­tu­re, 2019; 69 (8): 101–111. doi: 10.1016/j.gaitpost.2019.01.020

[4] Breg­man DJJ et al. A new method for eva­lua­ting ank­le foot ortho­sis cha­rac­te­ristics: BRUCE. Gait & Pos­tu­re, 2009; 30 (2): 144–149. doi: 10.1016/j.gaitpost.2009.05.012

[5] Ski­gen JT et al. Cus­to­mi­zed pas­si­ve-dyna­mic ank­le-foot ort­ho­ses can impro­ve wal­king eco­no­my and speed for many indi­vi­du­als post-stro­ke. Jour­nal of Neu­roEn­gi­nee­ring and Reha­bi­li­ta­ti­on, 2024; 21 (1): 126. doi: 10.1186/s12984-024–01425‑7

[6] Böhm H, Dus­sa CU. Pre­fa­bri­ca­ted ank­le-foot ort­ho­ses for child­ren with cere­bral pal­sy to over­co­me spas­tic drop-foot: does ortho­tic ank­le stiff­ness mat­ter? Pro­sthe­tics and Ortho­tics Inter­na­tio­nal, 2021; 45 (6): 491–499. doi: 10.1097/PXR.0000000000000050

[7] Water­val NFJ et al. Stiff­ness-opti­mi­zed ank­le-foot ort­ho­ses impro­ve wal­king ener­gy cost com­pared to con­ven­tio­nal ort­ho­ses in neu­ro­mus­cu­lar dis­or­ders: a pro­s­pec­ti­ve uncon­trol­led inter­ven­ti­on stu­dy. IEEE Tran­sac­tions on Neu­ral Sys­tems and Reha­bi­li­ta­ti­on Engi­nee­ring, 2020; 28 (10): 2296–2304. doi: 10.1109/TNSRE.2020.3018786

[8] Ker­kum YL et al. The effects of vary­ing ank­le foot ortho­sis stiff­ness on gait in child­ren with spas­tic cere­bral pal­sy who walk with exces­si­ve knee fle­xi­on. PLOS One, 2015; 10 (11): e0142878. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0142878

[9] Yama­mo­to S, Miya­za­ki S, Kubo­ta T. Quan­ti­fi­ca­ti­on of the effect of the mecha­ni­cal pro­per­ty of ank­le-foot ort­ho­ses on hemi­ple­gic gait. Gait & Pos­tu­re, 1993; 1 (1): 27–34. doi: 10.1016/0966–6362(93)90040–8

[10] van Noort L et al. A usa­bi­li­ty stu­dy on the inGAIT-VSO: effects of a varia­ble-stiff­ness ank­le-foot ortho­sis on the wal­king per­for­mance of child­ren with cere­bral pal­sy. Jour­nal of Neu­roEn­gi­nee­ring and Reha­bi­li­ta­ti­on, 2024; 21 (1): 132. doi: 10.1186/s12984-024–01433‑7

[11] Ker­kum YL, Phil­ip­part W, Hou­di­jk H. The effects of foot­plate stiff­ness on push-off power when wal­king with pos­te­ri­or leaf spring ank­le-foot ort­ho­ses. Cli­ni­cal Bio­me­cha­nics, 2021; 88 (2): 105422. doi: 10.1016/j.clinbiomech.2021.105422

[12] Rus­sell Espo­si­to E et al. How does ank­le-foot ortho­sis stiff­ness affect gait in pati­ents with lower limb sal­va­ge? Cli­ni­cal Ortho­pae­dics and Rela­ted Rese­arch, 2014; 472 (10): 3026–3035. doi: 10.1007/s11999-014‑3661‑3

[13] Water­val NFJ et al. Pre­cis­i­on ortho­tics: opti­mi­sing ank­le foot ort­ho­ses to impro­ve gait in pati­ents with neu­ro­mus­cu­lar dise­a­ses; pro­to­col of the PROOF-AFO stu­dy, a pro­s­pec­ti­ve inter­ven­ti­on stu­dy. BMJ Open, 2017; 7 (2): e013342. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2016–013342

[14] Schrö­der J‑H et al. Neu­ar­ti­ge modu­la­re Gehor­the­se zur leis­tungs­fä­hi­gen Kor­rek­tur von Gang­ab­wei­chun­gen bei neu­ro­lo­gisch beding­ten Geh­stö­run­gen. Ortho­pä­die Tech­nik, 2022; 73 (4): 62–67

[15] Haf­ke­mey­er U et al. Dyna­mi­sche Unter­schen­kel­or­the­se in Pre­preg-Tech­nik nach Haf­ke­mey­er – Kon­struk­ti­ons­merk­ma­le, Indi­ka­tio­nen, Varia­ti­ons­mög­lich­kei­ten. Ortho­pä­die Tech­nik, 2024; 75 (4): 48–54

[16] Wang JZ et al. Mecha­ni­cal test­ing methods for deter­mi­ning stiff­ness of ank­le-foot ort­ho­ses: a sco­ping review. Pro­sthe­tics and Ortho­tics Inter­na­tio­nal, 2025. doi: 10.1097/PXR.0000000000000478

[17] Smo­len­ski UC et al. Jan­da Manu­el­le Mus­kel­funk­ti­ons­dia­gnos­tik. 7. Auf­la­ge. Mün­chen: Urban & Fischer, 2025

[18] Kiril­l­ov M. Prü­fung und Bewer­tung von Unter­schen­kel-Orthe­sen. Tech­ni­sche Uni­ver­si­tät Ber­lin, 2026. doi: 10.14279/depositonce-26460

[19] Schwartz MH, Rozu­mal­ski A, Trost JP. The effect of wal­king speed on the gait of typi­cal­ly deve­lo­ping child­ren. Jour­nal of Bio­me­cha­nics, 2008; 41 (8): 1639–1650. doi: 10.1016/j.jbiomech.2008.03.015

[20] Stren­ge O, Hoch­mann D. Ana­ly­ti­cal stiff­ness pre­dic­tion method for idea­li­zed pas­si­ve dyna­mic ank­le-foot ort­ho­ses under stan­dar­di­zed bench test con­di­ti­ons. Tran­sac­tions on Addi­ti­ve Manu­fac­tu­ring Meets Medi­ci­ne, 2026; 8 (1): 2755. doi: 10.18416/AMMM.2026.26062755

 

Tei­len Sie die­sen Inhalt